koganbot: (Default)


I posted the following comment to David Cooper Moore's Favourite 50 at rockcritics.com:

My affinity list continues with David Cooper Moore: t.A.T.u.'s "Cosmos (Outer Space)," except I voted for "Kosmos,"* the Russian-language version – since I don't speak Russian, though, and the lyrics are a good part of the emotional wallop for me, I don't know why I didn't choose the English version. I guess once I get the basic meaning – "Another time, another place, another world"** – the wallop is in full effect no matter which language I'm hearing.

—Checking Google Translate, the idea is definitely the same – "Our home forever is outer space" vs. "We'll meet forever in space" – but there do seem to be pretty big differences, actually; the Russian version has nothing like my favorite line in the English, "Black stars and endless seas, outer space," but meanwhile the English, "Bridges burnt, fingers crossed... Same before, same again," simply can't compete with, "Tails are torn off, the legs are unscrewed, but – all the same, all the same," in the Russian.

Anyway, knowing both versions you get more meaning and better-confuted meaning!

*Тату's "Космос," if I want to go all Cyrillic.

**Pulled a fast one on you, didn't I? "Another time, another place, another world" isn't from "Cosmos," it's from Margaret Berger's "Robot Song"; like Dave, I'll sometimes put "Cosmos" back-to-back with "Robot Song" on playlists, the two songs of forbidden love.

[nb: Dave puts "Robot Song" and "Cosmos (Outer Space)" side-by-side on his list as numbers 4 and 5.]



koganbot: (Default)
"What is a nonsingle?" I hear you ask. A nonsingle is an album cut that never becomes a single and never acts like a single (so, doesn't get a lot of airplay or get talked about by more than one set of friends and doesn't chart for more than a couple of weeks), or it's a leaked track that wasn't leaked by the artist and doesn't act like a single (see previous parenthesis). So, for example, Jay-Z's "Takeover" was an album cut that was never pushed as a single, but it's not eligible in the nonsingles category, the reason being that it was chatted about and responded to all over the place, was the subject of an answer song, etc.

Top Five Nonsingles Of The '00s

1. t.A.T.u. "Kosmos" [English-language version is "Cosmos (Outer Space)"]
2. María Daniela Y Su Sonido Lasser "Duri Duri"
3. Margaret Berger "Robot Song"
4. Fannypack "Smack It Up"
5. Lindsay Lohan "Nobody 'Til You"

(Didn't do a 6 through 10, but if you want a top ten, just insert your five favorite Cassie leaks.)

"Kosmos" is the standard t.A.T.u. exploitation of their supposedly forbidden supposed love, and in all its transparent obviousness it is just utterly, exquisitely, beautifully moving. "Robot Song" does the same trick, forbidden romance as a gag, "I'm in love with a robot," and then fakes out the gag with its own exquisite beauty, is as intense for me as Murnau's Tabu or Ophuls' Earrings Of Madame de...; I like to program "Robot Song" and "Cosmos (Outer Space)" back-to-back: come to get me when the stars die, another time, another place, another world, you're the only one who makes me feel a thing, guilt for the second best, feel no more, feel no less, our home forever is outer space, black stars and endless seas, outer space, new hope, new destinies, outer space, forever we'll be in outer space.

"Smack It Up" is a bratsmack, and "Duri Duri" is a Mexican Italodisco '80s classic given it's own '00s smackiness. "Nobody 'Til You" is - what? - the second most beautiful John Shanks song, a gorgeous flood of guitar chords.
koganbot: (Default)
Wistful thoughts from some shorter members of the animal kingdom:

Expandt.A.T.u. )

ExpandCansei De Ser Sexy )

Profile

koganbot: (Default)
Frank Kogan

March 2025

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
1617 1819202122
23242526272829
3031     

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

Expand All Cut TagsCollapse All Cut Tags
Page generated Jun. 27th, 2025 12:54 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios