Black Tinkerbell

[koganbot]

New ChoColat single, "Black Tinkerbell," similar to their previous three in that there's a touch of mid-Eastern-by-way-of-Spain-and-Africa quasi-freestyle mournfulness,* and all four singers get time in the spotlight. Song provides no opportunity for an aching Melanie** wail à la the "I want it all, all or nothing" in "I Like It." But she gives us a nice emotive brushstroke at the end of the middle eight. And the other three are catching up to her in sounding forceful and assured. Track doesn't earworm me the way "One More Day" and "I Like It" did, though maybe it's going more for a steady mood than for hooks.

Watch on YouTube

What I mean by "freestyle" is more than one thing (see tag). ChoColat lean towards the passionate NY style, rather than the poppier Miami. And I wish the writers and arrangers for ChoColat would jump into the style whole hog, clear up space for vocal passion and hop up the beats and see what happens, e.g. (1989):

Cynthia "Change On Me"

Watch on YouTube

*Provided by songwriters from Britain, Norway, and America, respectively, on singles 1 through 3. I don't know yet who wrote "Black Tinkerbell." [UPDATE: But David Frazer does. It's Kim Eui Sung of the band Bring The Noiz, and this is his/her first commercial song, or idol song, or something.]

**Me being prescient sixteen months ago:

http://koganbot.livejournal.com/287310.html

Comments

Music shows

[davidfrazer.livejournal.com]

MBC Show Champion, 12th June



KBS Music Bank



Tia wasn't happy with this performance:

Today's performance was disappointing..We did so much better during rehearsalsㅠ I'm sorry!Next time we will do better! Thanks for tuning in!

Re: Music shows

[koganbot]

Thought it was pretty good, for live singing and dancing. They're not sharp, precision dancers like SNSD, but they're strong singers and have appealing moves. Soa was too soft and sometimes off-pitch, Juliane soft as well, while Tia and Melanie really delivered. Of course, sometimes the problem is the person doing sound, who's supposed to create the balance.