Links
Threads
Frank Stuff
- Bluesky
- Real Punks Don't Wear Black (reviewed)
- Death Rock 2000
- Superwords (go to thread and search "superword")
- Legend Of The Glockeater
- The Rules Of The Game
- koganbot YouTube playlists
- Mouthbeats And The Openhearted (long Substack ver.)
- Wan For The Win
- "I Am My Own Mommy, The Fuck!"
- Hallway-Classroom (go to thread and read down and up)
- T-ara
- "You’ve loved me and I’ve only given you disappointment. Please stop now." They don’t stop.
- Dresses Are My Weakness, Seriously
- The Disco Tex Essay
- The Social Butterfly Effect
- Where The Real Wild Things Are
- The Death Of The Cool
- The Spoonie Gee Trilogy
- They put the world off at a distance
- Hero Story
- Why Mucus Slacks (substack)
More Blogs and Such
- rockcritics.com
- Freaky Trigger
- People's Pop Polls at twitter
- People's Pop Polls at freaky trigger
- People's Pop Polls at bluesky
- Dave Moore's bluesky
- Dave Moore's fun Twitter
- Dave Moore's official twitter
- Cure For Bedbugs (Dave Moore)
- Dave Moore on Medium
- Sean Carroll's Mindscape podcast
- Gary Gramling's old Sports Illustrated content
- Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality
- Leslie Singer/Girls On Fire
- Duncan J. Watts
- Pinakothek (old) (Lucy Sante)
- Pinakothek (more recent) (Lucy Sante)
- Lucy's Substack (Lucy Sante)
- Freelance Mentalists (Don Allred et al.)
- Don Allred's Village Voice links
- Jessica Doyle's pillowfort
- Jessica Doyle's blog
- Tom Ewing at Freaky Trigger
- Hazel Southwell's Soundcloud
- Andrew Klimeyk's twitter
- Richard Kogan at CBPP
- Bobby Kogan's twitter
- David Kogan's twitter
- Mark Sinker's twitter
- mark sinker is creating a history of the uk music press
- Pinkmoose twitter
- Robert Christgau
- Matt Yglesias's twitter
- Holly Boson's bluesky
- Jonathan Bradley's twitter
- LokpoLokpo's bluesky
- Jel Bugle's bluesky
- Semipop Life (Brad Luen's substack)
- Brad Luen's substack notes
- Brad Luen's bluesky
- Chuck Eddy's bluesky
- Jeff Worrell's bluesky
- Katherine Morayati's twitter
- idca's bluesky
- Jonathan Bogart's bluesky
- Sarah Manvel
- Sarah Manvel's bluesky
- Centuries of Sound bluesky
- The Singles Jukebox
- Jamie Vinnycrackers
Active Entries
- 1: Another Year In America November 19, 2009
- 2: Confirmation
- 3: Rules Of The Game #6: The Boney Joan Rule
- 4: Boney Joan Returns!
- 5: Nathan Chapman
- 6: Ari Falcão
- 7: The Austral-Romanian Empire
- 8: Hoisted from the archives: Athletic R&B comments reconstituted
- 9: Bob Dylan
- 10: Background becomes foreground
Style Credit
- Style: Neutral Good for Practicality by
Expand Cut Tags
No cut tags
no subject
Date: 2016-05-14 10:31 pm (UTC)Once names start going on compositions we begin to move away from this fundamental self-understood paradigm. With classical music this is a challenge to authenticity but court forms + canons are also tightly embedded into specific cultural and historical paradigms so while authenticity might not be the predominant consideration it isn't entirely "inauthentic" either. Benjamin traces the destruction of authenticity to the crisis of reproduction - he is talking about lithographs but the move from live performance to recorded performance would carry some of the auratic destruction too that we see in the visual.
The authentic is immediate, it is personable, it is shared, it is present, it is historical, it does something. Importantly none of these descriptions apply particularly to the pop/rock canons of Western popular music which exists mostly to express the individuated personality of the performer, or to sell records (embedded tightly in a capitalist economic process). I think I agree with you here, Frank - poptimism did nothing different from rockism but change the characters. Both rock and pop share all the same deficiencies of authenticity from my pov. As an identity/diversity movement it was a success (bc now you can read about Beyonce in the New Yorker) but as an attempt to reclaim authenticity it made the assumption that some artists are more authentic than others but ignored the fact that replicability and authorship itself are the daggers at the heart of authenticity.
If you're not sure if this distinction is true go to your church, or choir, or perform a musical, or sing some tunes with some friends at a meal, and compare that participatory experience to the experience of listening to anyone else's recording in any other circumstance. (And to a lesser extent contrast a live concert to any home recording.) It is a vivid contrast.
What is much more interesting to me is the process by which authored music pass into an authentic folk vernacular ie when a song has become fully owned and assimilated into lived experiences of the general pop. Certain Chassidic Rebbes have said that melodies/tunes from a low source (like popular tavern drinking songs) can be transmuted into a higher plane by being used for ritual, holy purpose. Metaphorically this is how I understand a process of authentication working - something from an owned, gated, authored source becoming owned by the people at large. I don't know that poptimism created conditions by which this was more possible but I do think it's possible to argue that the songs they championed (extremely well selling + omnipresent tracks) are those more likely to be embraced on this broader collective level and that some of the songs they derided (extremely obscure, difficult, challenging compositions) were never accessible enough to the people.