Frank Kogan

I don't follow why you think Toop was intending to PBS-ify the ballad discourse -- based on what he said in the interview years later

I haven't read the original sleevenotes -- Tom has them, I hope he brings them to France! -- but surely the reason Toop makes clear his deep intentions in the interview is that he DIDN'T reveal them in the sleevenotes?

Anyway, the suggestion I wanted to raise -- which may not apply to Toop since neither of us have read these sleevenotes, though I do actually know his writing from that era pretty well -- is that there's a difference between "intending to PBS-ify" and "ending up PBS-ifying"; and that a key part of that difference is that "intending to AshBritify the ____ discourse" may end up PBS-ifying it. Indeed, this uh-oh dynamic seems pretty key: I think it's exactly what happened with the original (c.1982) idea of anti-rockism, for example -- the long-term effect was the opposite of the immediate intention.