koganbot: (Default)
Frank Kogan ([personal profile] koganbot) wrote2013-06-11 06:23 am

Black Tinkerbell

New ChoColat single, "Black Tinkerbell," similar to their previous three in that there's a touch of mid-Eastern-by-way-of-Spain-and-Africa quasi-freestyle mournfulness,* and all four singers get time in the spotlight. Song provides no opportunity for an aching Melanie** wail à la the "I want it all, all or nothing" in "I Like It." But she gives us a nice emotive brushstroke at the end of the middle eight. And the other three are catching up to her in sounding forceful and assured. Track doesn't earworm me the way "One More Day" and "I Like It" did, though maybe it's going more for a steady mood than for hooks.



What I mean by "freestyle" is more than one thing (see tag). ChoColat lean towards the passionate NY style, rather than the poppier Miami. And I wish the writers and arrangers for ChoColat would jump into the style whole hog, clear up space for vocal passion and hop up the beats and see what happens, e.g. (1989):

Cynthia "Change On Me"


*Provided by songwriters from Britain, Norway, and America, respectively, on singles 1 through 3. I don't know yet who wrote "Black Tinkerbell." [UPDATE: But David Frazer does. It's Kim Eui Sung of the band Bring The Noiz, and this is his/her first commercial song, or idol song, or something.]

**Me being prescient sixteen months ago:

http://koganbot.livejournal.com/287310.html

Get your makeup, boys don't cry

[identity profile] davidfrazer.livejournal.com 2013-06-11 01:55 pm (UTC)(link)
(Reposting from the other thread.)

The B-side is called All Night Long. It's a hip-hoppish R&B-ish song with a rap break by a male rapper, and I'm going to stick my neck out and suggest that the brass riffs sound freestyle-ish. :)



Jaeyoon's voice can reputedly be heard on All Night Long, which would mean that it's sat on the shelf for a few years. It would also mean that the "where's Jaeyoon?" and "omg I heard she had cancer!" comments on YouTube videos will never, ever end.

Side note about freestyle

[identity profile] davidfrazer.livejournal.com 2013-06-11 07:43 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't think I really knew what freestyle was until I started reading your blog, but there's one freestyle or freestyle-esque song I've known for a lot longer than that, and which I did know was "Latin" inspired -- Domino Dancing by the Pet Shop Boys.



The story goes that the Pet Shop Boys had written the song and wanted it to have a "Latin" sound, and after hearing lots of Exposé songs during a visit to the US they went to Miami and recorded it with Lewis Martinée.

[identity profile] davidfrazer.livejournal.com 2013-06-11 05:51 pm (UTC)(link)
Now we know who composed Black Tinkerbell, and he's not British or Norwegian. :)
According to the group’s agency, “Black Tinkerbell” is composed by rookie composer, Kim Eui Sung, who took almost two years to perfect this song made especially for the group. Kim Eui Sung was inspired to write this song after noticing that ChoColat often received compliments that the members were like fairies. The song is about loving someone who loves someone else, yet unable to leave, continuing to linger around the person you love.
h/t tsukumo at onehallyu and tweener42, who says that Kim Eui Sung is a member of a group called Bring the Noiz.
Edited 2013-06-11 17:54 (UTC)

[identity profile] davidfrazer.livejournal.com 2013-06-11 06:39 pm (UTC)(link)
pop!gasa has translated the lyrics to Black Tinkerbell:



I love you, I I wanna be with you
I love you, I

Don’t you see the childish me in your eyes?
Is love only possible when you’ve prepared for it when you’re young?
I’m too small for you and today, I really do seem small
To me, who is so small, even your love is small

Look at me next to you
I’m looking at you like this
My love may be short but
More than anything else, I live for you

Black Tinkerbell, I love you every day as I linger next to you
Black Tinkerbell, look at my choked up love because of you, my Peter Pan

I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you

How is her big love?
Even if you tell me, I wouldn’t know because I’m small
Is her love bigger than the times we had together?
Probably, because I’m too small

One can protect love with effort
But one can’t make love with effort
Before she came along
You’ve never been like this to me (never been like this)

Black Tinkerbell, I love you every day as I linger next to you
Black Tinkerbell, look at my choked up love because of you, my Peter Pan

I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you

My small wings can’t cover you
But her big smile covers you
After she came along, I became second
What are you going to do with me? Please love me

Black Tinkerbell, I love you every day as I linger next to you
Black Tinkerbell, look at my choked up love because of you, my Peter Pan

I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
I can’t leave, can’t leave, can’t leave you
Edited 2013-06-11 18:40 (UTC)

Chocolates returned

[identity profile] rjcd9.wordpress.com (from livejournal.com) 2013-06-14 09:02 am (UTC)(link)
I have some real mixed thoughts about this one. I do think Melanies ace vocals are under-utilised but Black Tinkerbell does have a nice sound to it. Mostly just glad their label hasn't given up on them yet.

Music shows

[identity profile] davidfrazer.livejournal.com 2013-06-16 09:28 pm (UTC)(link)
MBC Show Champion, 12th June



KBS Music Bank



Tia wasn't happy with this performance:
Today's performance was disappointing..We did so much better during rehearsalsㅠ I'm sorry!Next time we will do better! Thanks for tuning in!


Tinkering with Tinkerbell

[identity profile] davidfrazer.livejournal.com 2013-07-08 07:43 pm (UTC)(link)
Chocolat were interviewed today on Arirang Radio's Sound K. To explain why it took so long for them to come back, they said that after they first heard Black Tinkerbell the song was rewritten and rearranged with a faster tempo, and they ended up re-recording the vocals. Because the lyrics are rather verbose and the song was sped up, it's hard to sing fast enough and dance at the same time (one of the girls, I don't know who, likened it to rapping).

Tia loves R&B and hip-hop, so perhaps she might like vintage freestyle too. :)

By the way, Tia has said that she wants to rap, and in this Haruman Deo/One More Day/Same Thing To Her fancam she sings along with the recording of the guest rapper.