I'm sure the primary author will have seen it at least. I used "implicit nastiness" because no one's tone in the post or the thread was outright nasty, just building off some assumptions whose foundation is a bit of a sneer (potentially). My fave post was the description of the impetus for the project as told by Turnage's wife -- his son hummed the song around the house all the time! And my second fave was the classical music critic admitting he's never heard "Single Ladies." Both seemed to be reaching toward a more honest discussion of motivations and/or blind spots (or any number of things one might discuss with this piece as the impetus).