Dave talks a little about the critical response (or nonresponse) to Fall Out Boy here

Apparently, I am "not authorized to view this protected entry." What does Dave say? (I did just check the two Xgau CG's on his site -- a C+ and a B- -- though those are mediocre grades, not devastating ones. And may or may not be typical -- though, yeah, C+/B- sounds about right to me.)